“I Think Not!” delivers a distinctive blend of true crime narratives and comedic commentary, hosted by best friends Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto. The podcast explores a wide array of real-life cases, from perplexing unsolved mysteries, often referencing classic true crime television like "Unsolved Mysteries," to contemporary legal proceedings and breaking news in the true crime world. The hosts infuse each discussion with their unique brand of irreverent humor, personal anecdotes, and campy observations, creating an engaging and often hilarious take on grim subjects. This show is ideal for true crime aficionados who appreciate a lighter, more satirical, and less conventional approach, offering a refreshing way to engage with the genre through laughter and sharp wit.