How to advertise on Was I in a Cult?: what it costs, who buys, and how to book

Cam Pritchard
CEO & Founder | Podcast Advertising Expert
Host-read inventory on this show is sold direct and quoted per campaign, not off a published rate card, and the ad mix tells you exactly what it's being bought for: Spotsnow estimates more than 95% of the ads tracked here are direct-response. The anchor buyer, If These Walls Could Rock, has run roughly 5 to 6 ads, all host-read, all coded or linked. For a buyer, that combination means you're walking into a feed where performance brands have already tested the format and come back, which is a different proposition than buying reach and hoping. Spotsnow estimates all of this from tracked advertiser activity, not audience surveys.
The show in question is Was I in a Cult?, a documentary-style interview podcast built around first-person accounts of leaving high-control groups.

Why Was I in a Cult? is built for host-read direct response
The show is hosted by documentary filmmaker Tyler Measom alongside Liz Iacuzzi, and it sits in true crime, with crossover into society and culture, education, and history.
Spotsnow attributes more than 95% of ad activity here to direct response, which is about as lopsided as this category gets. That matters because direct response needs a measurable handoff: a code, a vanity URL, a spoken offer the listener can act on. Host-read delivers that, produced spots mostly don't.
The format argument is the real one. Episodes are long-form, single-narrative interviews where a survivor walks through what happened to them. Listeners don't skim that. They stay in sequence, because skipping ahead means losing the thread of someone's story. A host-read spot inside that structure borrows the same posture the hosts use throughout the episode, measured, curious, not performing. Spotsnow estimates the show reaches roughly 67,000 listeners, an estimated figure, and the audience skews strongly female, lands mostly in the younger and middle adult range, is broadly middle income, and is heavily concentrated in the US.
Proof of engagement sits in the feed itself. The show carries about a 4.5 star average on Apple Podcasts across roughly 3,170 to 3,500 ratings, a review volume that's unusual for a show this size. Its influence is concentrated where it converts, inside the episode and in the review pile, rather than spread thin across social platforms. For a performance buyer that's the better version: attention pooled in one place you can actually buy into.
Who is advertising on Was I in a Cult?
Spotsnow data shows roughly 21 to 24 distinct brands running in the recent window, split between coded DTC host-reads and produced network drops from much larger advertisers. The most recognizable names include Whatnot, Quince, Boll & Branch, Zenni, and Wayfair.
The anchor advertisers, broken down
If These Walls Could Rock
A narrative music and culture show, and the top on-show spender in Spotsnow's data at an estimated over $4K across roughly 5 to 6 ads. Spotsnow classifies it as fully direct-response and entirely host-read. It's a niche buyer rather than a national one, and that's the point: a show chasing listeners who sit still for a long story is buying the exact appetite this feed has already proven.
Whatnot

Whatnot runs livestream auctions for collectibles, fashion, beauty, and electronics. Spotsnow attributes an estimated over $3K in on-show spend across roughly 2 to 3 host-read ads, and classifies the brand as direct-response. It's also one of the heaviest podcast spenders in the whole Spotsnow dataset, which makes its presence on a show this size a deliberate targeting decision, not spillover. A female-skewing audience that already enjoys watching a story unfold in real time is primed for a live auction.
Zenni
Zenni sells low-cost prescription eyewear online. Spotsnow estimates over $2K in on-show spend from about 1 host-read ad, classified direct-response. Eyewear is a clean coded-offer category for a practical, value-conscious, mostly US audience, and the test-then-scale pattern Spotsnow shows across Zenni's broader buying suggests this feed was a probe rather than a one-off.
The outlier: Progressive Insurance
Progressive is the most frequent recent advertiser in the feed and runs entirely produced spots, with no host-read at all. Spotsnow classifies none of that activity as direct-response. It's evidence that a second objective works here too: a national brand using the show as cheap, contextually safe frequency, bought programmatically rather than negotiated with the hosts.
| Brand | Est. total spend | Direct-response | Time of spend (last 1 year) |
|---|---|---|---|
| If These Walls Could Rock | over $4K | Yes, host-read | July to August |
| Whatnot | over $3K | Yes, host-read | July to August |
| Zenni | over $2K | Yes, host-read | July |
All spend figures are Spotsnow estimates.
Why true crime brands cluster here
True crime advertising usually gets explained as morbid curiosity sold at scale. That's not what's happening on this show. The subject is coercive control and recovery from it, and the hosts handle it with a documentarian's caution, which produces a listener who is skeptical by disposition and unusually alert to being sold to. Counterintuitively, that's the audience host-read works best on, because the only pitch they'll accept is one that sounds like a person vouching rather than a script being read.
Look at what actually buys here and the pattern holds. Livestream auctions, affordable glasses, cheap-luxury basics, bedding. Nothing aspirational, nothing status-driven. These are brands whose entire pitch is that you're not being taken for a ride, pitched to an audience built around people who were. Spotsnow attributes more than 95% of activity here to direct response because the trust transfer is real enough to survive a promo code. If your product needs a credibility assist to clear the first purchase, that's the trade worth paying for.
What makes a show like this convert
- The format keeps people in the episode. Long-form single-narrative interviews punish skipping ahead, so a mid-roll lands with the listener still in sequence.
- Host credibility is documentary credibility. Tyler Measom's filmmaking background sets the show's tone, and a host who is careful about facts is a host whose endorsement carries weight.
- The audience is buyable, not just big. Spotsnow estimates roughly 67,000 listeners, an estimate, skewing strongly female and concentrated in the US, which is the profile most DTC offers are already built against.
- Advertisers come back. Spotsnow data shows the anchor buyer has run roughly 5 to 6 ads here, and nobody repeats a host-read buy at that rate unless the attribution is clearing.
Was I in a Cult? in a nutshell
Spotsnow estimates an audience of roughly 67,000 listeners that skews strongly female and sits mostly in the US, with middle-income buying behavior. The buyers already in the feed split two ways: coded host-reads from DTC brands like Whatnot and Zenni, and produced network spots from national advertisers such as Progressive and Wayfair. Inventory is sold direct and quoted per campaign, so pricing depends on placement, read type, and flight length rather than a public card. With more than 95% of tracked activity classified as direct response, Spotsnow data points this show at performance buyers first, with awareness frequency available as a secondary play.
Frequently asked questions
Was I in a Cult? is sold on a quoted basis rather than a public rate card. Four things move the number: placement (mid-roll host-read prices above pre-roll and post-roll), read type (a host endorsement prices above a produced spot), commitment length (multi-episode flights and category exclusivity price better than a single test), and how close you are to the air date. For market context, a host-read spot on a typical show costs a brand roughly $20 to $30 for every thousand listeners it reaches. In-demand shows clear well above that. The more useful signal for this show is who already buys: Whatnot has run roughly 2 to 3 ads, alongside Zenni and If These Walls Could Rock. Repeat buying at that level tells you more about where a show prices, and what it's worth to the brands buying it, than an outside estimate can.
Ads run on most episodes, so the show is in demand and inventory moves fast. Plan on reaching out sooner than you think you need to.
Budget about 1 week to book, 2 to 3 weeks to produce and run, plus 2 to 3 weeks of lead time, so roughly 5 to 7 weeks end to end.
Was I in a Cult? is sold direct rather than through one of the large networks. You can approach the hosts, or book through a platform that already has the show in its inventory. You can view different advertising platforms here.
Both, and the split is worth understanding before you brief. Spotsnow data shows the DTC buyers, Whatnot, Quince, Zenni, Boll & Branch, all run host-read with coded offers, while larger advertisers like Progressive, Wayfair, and Whole Foods Market appear as produced drops. If you want attribution, you want the host-read. If you want cheap frequency against a true crime audience, the produced path exists.
Was I in a Cult? isn't the only feed reaching this audience. Spotsnow shows which true crime podcasts have host-read spots open right now, and which brands already buy them.
Get on the last minute spots email list.
Find incredible discounts and opportunities on premium shows.
Get on the last minute spots email list.
Find incredible discounts and opportunities on premium shows.