How to advertise on MrCreepyPasta's Storytime: what it costs, who buys, and how to book

Lex Quintilla
Advertiser Partnerships Manager
MrCreepyPasta's Storytime sells its host-read inventory direct, quoted per campaign rather than off a public rate card, and Spotsnow data shows every tracked host-read ad on the show is direct-response. That's unusual for a horror fiction feed, where awareness buys normally dominate. The top host-read anchor, Banyan Botanicals, has run roughly 5 to 6 host-read appearances on the show, which tells you this is a feed where coded offers get retested rather than tried once. If you're a DTC brand that needs attribution on every dollar, that mix matters more than the genre does. Spotsnow estimates all of this from tracked advertiser activity, not audience surveys.

The full advertiser history and spend detail sits on the MrCreepyPasta's Storytime profile on Spotsnow.
Why MrCreepyPasta's Storytime is built for host-read direct response
The show is narrated by MrCreepyPasta, the "Blue Man" himself, a long-running creepypasta narrator who built the podcast straight out of his YouTube channel of the same name. It sits in fiction, and its biggest-spending advertiser, Etsy, comes out of information technology & services, which is the kind of cross-category fit buyers usually miss in horror.
Spotsnow attributes 100% of the show's tracked host-read activity to direct-response campaigns. That means codes, vanity URLs and trackable offers, not soft brand impressions you have to argue for in a quarterly review. The format argument here is simple: narrated horror holds a listener in one continuous story, and a break in that story is not something people skip past casually. They are waiting for the narration to resume. A host-read borrows exactly that attention, because the voice that has been building dread for twenty minutes is the voice reading your offer. Spotsnow estimates reach at roughly 74,000 listeners per episode, an estimated figure, and that audience skews young, runs close to an even gender split, sits mostly in middle income brackets and is heavily US-based with a smaller UK and Canada tail.
On engagement, the show carries a 4.8 average Apple Podcasts rating on roughly 2,360 to 2,752 ratings, and the host's YouTube channel counts roughly 1.7 million subscribers. The influence is concentrated in the feed and on YouTube rather than spread thin across half a dozen social platforms, which is why the endorsement lands in audio: that's where the relationship actually lives.
Who is advertising on MrCreepyPasta's Storytime
Spotsnow data shows roughly 247 to 288 brands running on the show over the last three months, a deep roster that leans heavily on produced national spots with a handful of host-read anchors doing the conversion work. Recognizable names in the recent mix include McDonald's, American Express, Amazon Prime, BMW and Sleep Number.
The anchor advertisers, broken down
Banyan Botanicals
Ayurvedic herbs and wellness supplements. Banyan Botanicals has run roughly 5 to 6 appearances on the show, with estimated total spend over $500K, and Spotsnow classifies it as direct-response, read by the host. The fit is about ritual: this is a late-night, headphones-on, winding-down audience, and sleep and calm products sell best to people already in that state.
Etsy

A marketplace for handmade goods, vintage finds and craft supplies. Etsy keeps a lower on-show appearance count than the other anchors but carries estimated total spend over $100K, and Spotsnow classifies its activity as a mix of direct-response and awareness. Horror has a merch culture, from enamel pins to prints to oddities, so a marketplace of independent makers is selling something this crowd already shops for.
Spin Quest
A social casino and spin-based gaming platform. Spin Quest is the most frequent of the three at roughly 32 to 37 appearances in the last three months, with estimated total spend over $100K, classified by Spotsnow as direct-response. Mobile gaming and long-form narrated audio share the same occasion: something to do with your hands while something else holds your ears.
The outlier: Amazon Prime
Amazon Prime shows up differently. The host reads a plug for his own Creepypasta Collection books, pointing listeners to Amazon and other retailers with no code and no tracking link attached. It's a promotion read, not a coded offer, and it proves an awareness-style endorsement can sit comfortably in this feed if the thing being sold genuinely belongs to the show's world.
| Brand | Est. total spend | Direct-response | Time of spend (last 1 year) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Banyan Botanicals | Over $500K | Yes, host-read | Active through mid-2026 |
| Etsy | Over $100K | Mixed | Active across the year |
| Spin Quest | Over $100K | Yes | Active, heavy in recent months |
All spend figures are Spotsnow estimates.
Why fiction brands cluster here
Horror fiction gets underbought because buyers assume a scary story is a bad neighbor for a brand. The spend says otherwise. What the host actually sells is trust in a voice: listeners pick this feed because they want to be told a story by this particular narrator, and across roughly 2,360 to 2,752 Apple ratings at a 4.8 average, they keep showing up for it. A narrator's credential is delivery, and delivery is the whole product of a host-read.
Then there's the mindset. This is a feed people put on at night, alone, often with headphones, usually while doing nothing else. That's a state of high attention and low distraction, which is why wellness, marketplace and gaming offers all convert here despite having nothing in common with each other. Spotsnow attributes every tracked host-read on the show to direct-response, and brands don't repeat a coded offer in a feed where the code isn't getting used.
How your ad could sound

Host-read on MrCreepyPasta's Storytime
What works: the handoff is completely natural. He drops out of the story and into first person without a jingle or a tonal reset, and the framing is personal rather than transactional, calling the writers "some of my absolute favorite authors, and some of my friends." The where-to-buy is clear and low pressure. Nobody is being sold at.
What's worth fixing: there's no code, no urgency and no single destination. "Wherever you like to get books" is friendly and completely untrackable, which is a problem if your flight has to prove out. The self-deprecating aside about the audiobook, "I don't know why Simon & Schuster did that," is charming and also buries the offer right where the CTA should land. If you brief a read on this show, give the host one URL, one code and one reason to act this week, then let him keep the voice exactly as it is.
View what a great sample ad looks like here.
What makes a show like this convert
- The format does the work. Spotsnow attributes 100% of tracked host-read activity on the show to direct-response, so codes and URLs are the native currency here, not an afterthought.
- Host credibility transfers. A 4.8 Apple rating and roughly 1.7 million YouTube subscribers mean listeners are there for the narrator, and the endorsement rides on that.
- The audience is reachable and undistracted. Spotsnow estimates roughly 74,000 listeners, skewing young, mostly US-based, listening in long uninterrupted sessions.
- Brands come back. Banyan Botanicals has run roughly 5 to 6 host-read appearances and Spin Quest roughly 32 to 37 in three months. Repeat buying at that cadence means the math cleared.
MrCreepyPasta's Storytime in a nutshell
The listener base is young, close to evenly split by gender, mostly middle income and concentrated in the US, with Spotsnow estimating roughly 74,000 listeners. Wellness, marketplace and gaming brands already buy here, with the conversion work happening in host-read endorsements and the national volume arriving as produced insertions. The show sells direct and quotes per campaign, and ads run on most episodes, so inventory does not sit around. Treat it as a direct-response buy with a coded offer, not a reach-and-association play.
Frequently asked questions
MrCreepyPasta's Storytime is sold on a quoted basis rather than a public rate card. Four things move the number: placement (mid-roll host-read prices above pre-roll and post-roll), read type (a host endorsement prices above a produced spot), commitment length (multi-episode flights and category exclusivity price better than a single test), and how close you are to the air date. For market context, a host-read spot on a typical show costs a brand roughly $20 to $30 for every thousand listeners it reaches. In-demand shows clear well above that. The more useful signal for this show is who already buys: Banyan Botanicals has run roughly 5 to 6 host-read runs, alongside Etsy and Spin Quest. Repeat buying at that level tells you more about where a show prices, and what it's worth to the brands buying it, than an outside estimate can.
Ads run on most episodes, so the show is in demand and inventory moves fast. Plan on reaching out sooner than you think you need to.
Figure about 1 week to book, 2 to 3 weeks to produce and run, plus 2 to 3 weeks of lead time, so roughly 5 to 7 weeks end to end.
MrCreepyPasta's Storytime is sold direct rather than through one of the large networks. You can approach the host directly, or book through a platform that already has the show in its inventory. You can view different advertising platforms here.
Direct-response, clearly. Spotsnow attributes 100% of the show's tracked host-read activity to direct-response campaigns, which means a coded offer or a vanity URL is the right brief. Awareness reads can work, as the host's own book promotion shows, but you'd be buying against the grain of what already performs in this feed.
MrCreepyPasta's Storytime isn't the only feed reaching this audience. Spotsnow shows which fiction podcasts have host-read spots open right now, and which brands already buy them.
Get on the last minute spots email list.
Find incredible discounts and opportunities on premium shows.
Get on the last minute spots email list.
Find incredible discounts and opportunities on premium shows.